Jerry Coyne brings up the complaint that many have against atheism that it does not fulfill the same needs that religion fulfills for people.
I partially agree with this complaint, in that I believe atheism does not fulfill the same needs religion fulfills for people. However, I also believe it is not the responsibility of atheism to fulfill those needs. Atheism is not enough in regards to building a healthy, positive worldview, but it doesn't have to be: atheism is the elimination of a false-positive worldview. Atheism clears the field so that a person can build a positive worldview grounded in reality. This is not a problem specific to 'New' Atheism, this is a problem of atheism in general. Well, it's not actually a problem of atheism: it's a problem of people seeking meaning in this life; probably more so a problem of people seeking positive meaning in life after they have left religion. It's a conceptual problem. Atheism has removed an illusion from our eyes: we can't ask it to construct a new one.
Atheism is a leveler: we have to build our own hope.
I partially agree with this complaint, in that I believe atheism does not fulfill the same needs religion fulfills for people. However, I also believe it is not the responsibility of atheism to fulfill those needs. Atheism is not enough in regards to building a healthy, positive worldview, but it doesn't have to be: atheism is the elimination of a false-positive worldview. Atheism clears the field so that a person can build a positive worldview grounded in reality. This is not a problem specific to 'New' Atheism, this is a problem of atheism in general. Well, it's not actually a problem of atheism: it's a problem of people seeking meaning in this life; probably more so a problem of people seeking positive meaning in life after they have left religion. It's a conceptual problem. Atheism has removed an illusion from our eyes: we can't ask it to construct a new one.
Atheism is a leveler: we have to build our own hope.
I agree, but what do you think about "big tent atheism"? My own opinion is that atheism is poor branding and needs a renewed effort to build an atheism plus, without using the atheist label. And it needs to identify a set of core beliefs beyond antitheism. I don't believe in "big tent atheism", but it seems to be the best strategy right now. Let a thousand flowers bloom!
ReplyDeleteyes, i agree with your points. New' Atheism, this is a problem of atheism in general. It is a conceptual problem.
ReplyDeleteabsolute belief is nothing is as undefenseable as a an absolute belief in something...all very iffy on any level
ReplyDeleteAnonymous: I don't believe in anchoring ourselves to atheism at all. I think we should go out into the world and be good and do good, advance reason, science, and humanism, and watch as religion gradually dissolves in the current of progress.
ReplyDelete